How Old School Labs Found the Sales Its Reports Missed

Old School Labs had lost a quarter of its revenue in a year, and every report it received showed the spend working. We cut what failed an on and off test, freeing more than six figures a month in cash, and rebuilt acquisition around three customer groups, measured against total sales on the website and Amazon. Revenue grew 87% in 10 months and EBITDA tripled.

Old School Labs
Industry
Ecommerce, DTC and CPG, Food, beverage and restaurants
Region
US
Company type
Consumer brand (supplements)
When
2018 to 2020
Our role
Interim CMO (Omar Trejo, before Fourth Order Intel): paid media and growth strategy

The result

+87% revenue, 3× EBITDA

In 10 months against the same months a year earlier, after falling 25% the year before. Amazon sales fell 20 to 30% within three days of pausing Facebook ads; website return 3 to 1, true return 7 to 1.

Challenge

Old School Labs had built the number one pre-workout. Then Amazon launched a white-labeled copy of the flagship product and took the top ranking, and a competitor pushed the brand out of its second slot. Revenue fell 25% in a year.

The company's spending had not changed with the market. It ran six social channels with two social media managers, a full-time video producer, outside writers, designers and an SEO vendor, plus a CRM for a business whose sales flowed almost entirely through Amazon. The website sent every visitor to Amazon, so the brand had no store and no customer list of its own.

Each part reported on its own terms. Finance closed the books each month and the media vendor reported from inside the ad platforms. The SEO vendor's scope ended at clicks. Every report showed the work on track while sales kept falling.

Solution

What the audit found

Customers were loyal to reviews and search rank more than to the brand. When the product slipped in Amazon's rankings, people bought something else.

We tested each cost by switching it off. Organic posting stopped across the social channels and revenue stayed flat. The paid social spend, as it was then set up, came off and revenue held. Those were costs with no measurable return. Cutting them, along with the CRM, other tools and roles whose output could not be tied to revenue, freed more than six figures a month in cash for the business to reinvest.

The customer data showed three groups. Two were expected: people losing weight and people building muscle. The third bought a testosterone booster in isolation, and when we asked, they were older men noticing their energy and strength drop. That product cost twice as much to acquire and returned less than a dollar per dollar of ad spend on the first order. It recovered its acquisition cost in two months, against four months for the product with the higher first-order return, and those customers stayed about three times longer. It was the most profitable group in the business.

What the fix had to do

Growth had to come from the budget the business already had, since the money freed by the cuts was the reinvestment. Each dollar had to be judged on contribution to the whole business, including Amazon, where a website pixel cannot see. And the brand needed a store of its own, so it could keep a customer list and sell more than one product to each buyer.

What we did after the audit

We moved the brand onto its own Shopify store and rebuilt the ads from scratch. We cut footage from an abandoned video into many versions and tested them against a long list of headlines, and read comments and reviews for what buyers cared about. That led to changes on the website and the container, and in the order products were offered: protein first, then the pre-workout or the fat burner.

We built creative for each of the three groups and changed the influencer mix toward people the buyers wanted to look like. Budget went to the customers already buying, and it moved toward the group with the fastest payback.

We measured the ads against total sales on the website and Amazon together. When an analyst argued the Facebook spend was too high, we paused it for three days. Website sales nearly stopped apart from repeat orders, and Amazon sales fell 20 to 30%. The website reports had shown a return of 3 to 1. Counting Amazon, the true return was 7 to 1, and the spend went back on.

What we delivered

Old School Labs left with an owned store, a customer list, creative and messaging for each customer group, and a way of judging spend by its effect on total sales instead of what one channel's report claimed. The brand regained the top ranking on Amazon once the ads were running.

Results

Cutting tools and roles that could not be tied to revenue freed more than six figures a month in cash. Revenue grew 87% in 10 months against the same months a year earlier, after falling 25% the year before, and EBITDA tripled.

Key takeaway

Before you cut or scale a channel that looks weak in its own report, switch it off for a few days and watch total sales.

Industries: Ecommerce, DTC and CPG, Food, beverage and restaurants

Know what to fix first and what to leave alone.

Find problem areas today with the Market Health Analysis. It's $350, credited toward your Diagnostic.

Get your Market Health Analysis

Book a demo

See the dashboards, and how they would read your own numbers. We’ll email you to set up a time.

We use these details only to reply to you. See our privacy policy.