How 1-800 Contacts Cut Overtime by Changing Who Answered Email

1-800 Contacts' chat team was working 50 to 60 hours a week and still missing its targets, and the default answer was more overtime. Moving email to one dedicated person cleared the queues and ended the overtime with no layoffs, cutting more than $250K in cost.

1-800 Contacts
Industry
Healthcare
Region
US
Company type
Consumer health retailer
Our role
Operations and customer research, in-house

The result

$250K cut

One task reassignment ended the overtime and cleared the queues, with no layoffs.

Challenge

The digital support team was a group of about 20 specially trained agents. Each handled two live chats at a time, against a seven-minute target, and was also expected to answer an email every 10 minutes.

Queues reached 20 to 30 waiting customers and the team was missing its targets, so the problem looked like capacity. The company offered overtime, then added incentives: higher pay per hour and extra paid time off. Agents were working 50 to 60 hours a week and burning out, and the business was at risk of losing its best people, when it took about a month to train a replacement.

Solution

What the audit found

The constraint was attention. An agent was holding two live customers in separate windows while an email about a shipping problem waited, and switching between them all shift. Research by Sophie Leroy (2009), and earlier by Rubinstein, Meyer and Evans (2001), shows part of a person's attention stays on the task it left, so every conversation took longer than it should.

The volume was lower than it looked. Part of it came from the same customers contacting the company twice, through a second channel, because the first had not answered yet. Slow email was creating its own chat traffic.

What the fix had to do

The fix could not add people or cut anyone, since both would take weeks and neither addressed the cause. It had to work within the team's existing tools and training, and it had to bring handle times and queues back within target without asking agents for more hours.

What we did after the audit

We separated the work. One agent per shift handled only email, and with saved responses could clear most messages in about a minute, because email does not need a live back-and-forth. Everyone else handled chat without an inbox competing for their attention.

We then applied the same logic to the prescription team, a larger group of 50 to 60 agents who also handled faxes. One person each day handled only faxes.

What we delivered

Both teams kept a staffing pattern built around one type of work per person per shift, and a way to read workload by what an agent had to hold in mind, instead of by message count alone.

Results

Chat volume dropped as email cleared, and average chat handle time fell to about three and a half minutes against a seven-minute target. The queues disappeared.

Overtime and the extra time-off incentives ended with no layoffs, and more than $250K in cost came out. The team kept its people.

Key takeaway

Before you hire or pay for more hours, check whether the team is switching between too many kinds of work. At 1-800 Contacts, the savings came from who did which task.

Industries: Healthcare

Know what to fix first and what to leave alone.

Find problem areas today with the Market Health Analysis. It's $350, credited toward your Diagnostic.

Get your Market Health Analysis

Book a demo

See the dashboards, and how they would read your own numbers. We’ll email you to set up a time.

We use these details only to reply to you. See our privacy policy.