How an Insurance Startup Made Its Payment Step Feel Safe

A direct-to-consumer life insurance startup needed older buyers to enter a Social Security number and payment details online, with no agent on the phone. Design changes alone took that step from almost no completed payments to 1% of all visitors paying, and the business reached its first $1M in six weeks.

Private insurance startup
Industry
Healthcare
Region
US
Company type
Startup, insurance
When
2021 to 2022
Our role
Founding partner: product design and marketing technology

The result

First $1M in 6 weeks

Design alone took the payment step from 0 to 1% of traffic. Integrated carriers: American Amicable and Occidental.

Challenge

The business sold final expense life insurance directly to consumers, most of them older buyers who were wary of doing anything important online. Agents usually sell insurance like this, so they can answer questions and calm nerves. Here, the whole application ran on a website.

That application was long. It qualified the buyer, ran them through a decision engine, then asked for health and identity details, including a Social Security number, before payment, and ended with the terms and an electronic signature. The model only worked if strangers would finish it alone, and at the start almost every applicant stopped before the end.

Solution

What the audit found

We could get leads. A large share of visitors gave their contact details. The losses came later, and they came from fear. At the payment step, buyers did not know whether the site was safe or whether they would be charged that day.

The data also showed when and where people bought. Some days of the month did not produce sales, because buyers had not been paid yet. Some areas produced cheap leads and strong sales because few insurers were reaching those households, which was an opening and a risk for the lead side of the business.

What the fix had to do

Buyers had to be able to apply and pay without help, on a phone, inside the rules the two carriers and their compliance teams set. The carriers could not change the product, so every gain had to come from the experience around it. And each test had to be cheap and fast, because a slow, expensive redesign would run out of money before it found the answer.

What we did after the audit

We started at the end of the flow and worked backward, fixing the biggest drop-off and then the next one.

At the payment step, we answered the buyer's questions before they typed anything. The page showed which cards were accepted and displayed the security certificate, and it told buyers they controlled the payment and would not be charged yet. Then we rebuilt the eligibility screen as a moment of good news, with the quote right there, so the price felt reasonable before the hard questions began. We added live chat to answer questions while buyers were deciding, and guides to help them choose how much coverage they needed without over-buying.

We redesigned the compliance pages and disclosures, and made the application easy to sign on a phone. That took constant work between compliance, underwriting, the marketing team and the leadership of American Amicable and Occidental, the carriers integrated into the platform.

What we delivered

The business ran on a complete marketing technology platform: lead capture, a decision engine, application submission into the carrier, and a marketplace where agencies could buy leads and send them into their own CRM.

Results

Design alone took the payment step from almost no completed payments to 1% of all visitors paying, and the business reached its first $1M in sales in six weeks.

Key takeaway

People pay online when the page answers their worries before they type anything. Start at the last step and work backward.

Industries: Healthcare

Know what to fix first and what to leave alone.

Find problem areas today with the Market Health Analysis. It's $350, credited toward your Diagnostic.

Get your Market Health Analysis

Book a demo

See the dashboards, and how they would read your own numbers. We’ll email you to set up a time.

We use these details only to reply to you. See our privacy policy.