How Pool Fence DIY Cut Lead Costs Without Changing Ads

Pool Fence DIY's leads cost $60, and the CEO believed the targeting was the problem. We left the ads and the budget alone and rewrote the landing page for the parent making the decision. Lead cost fell to $15, and the business passed $2M in its first year.

Pool Fence DIY
Industry
Home services
Region
US
Company type
Ecommerce, home products
Our role
Landing page and paid media

The result

Lead cost $60 to $15

Same ads, same budget; the landing page rewritten for the household decision-maker. More than $2M in year one.

Challenge

Pool Fence DIY sells safety fences for residential pools, to homeowners who install them themselves or through a local dealer. Leads were costing $60 each. The CEO needed that under $50, or he would cut the program.

The obvious suspect was the media. If leads are expensive, change the targeting or change the vendor. Either of those would have reset months of learning and cost more money before anyone knew whether it helped.

Solution

What the audit found

The ads were doing their job. People clicked, and they clicked for the right reasons. The loss happened after the click.

The landing page was written for the installer. It described the product's features and suggested a lot of work with no payoff yet. The video showed how durable the fence was. The person deciding whether to buy was a parent, and that parent was weighing a different question: whether their child was safe around the pool.

The page sold the product as a fence. To the buyer, it was part of being a parent who keeps their kids safe, and the page never made that connection.

What the fix had to do

The test had to isolate the page. Nothing in the ad account changed, and the CEO checked its change history to make sure. The new page had to cost the client nothing to try, and it had to show a result fast enough to save the program.

What we did after the audit

We rewrote the landing page as a sales letter for the parent. It started with the risk, using news coverage of drownings, and the line "You wouldn't drive a car without a seat belt. Don't own a pool without a pool fence."

Then it answered the questions a parent asks next: what the fence looks like in a real backyard, and whether to install it themselves or have a local dealer do it. The offer was a free quote. Every section tied back to one identity, a parent who keeps their kids safe.

Once the page brought lead cost down, we turned the same story into new ads, including the news coverage, which brought costs down further.

What we delivered

Pool Fence DIY kept a landing page and a message sequence built around the parent's decision, and ads that carried the same story from the first impression to the quote request.

Results

Cost per lead fell from $60 to $15 on the same ads and the same budget, against the CEO's $50 target. The business passed $2M in its first year.

Key takeaway

When the ads work and the sales don't, check who the page is written for before you change the targeting.

Industries: Home services

Know what to fix first and what to leave alone.

Find problem areas today with the Market Health Analysis. It's $350, credited toward your Diagnostic.

Get your Market Health Analysis

Book a demo

See the dashboards, and how they would read your own numbers. We’ll email you to set up a time.

We use these details only to reply to you. See our privacy policy.