How SurePayroll Learned Why a Free Year Wasn't Selling

SurePayroll was giving away up to a year of payroll, and it still was not selling. We joined its sales and marketing data and showed the problem started with the product and the offer instead of the media. The homepage it runs today (2026) came out of our walkthrough.

SurePayroll
Industry
SaaS and technology, B2B
Region
US
Company type
Payroll software
Our role
Marketing data and offer strategy

The result

Reporting that holds

Campaign tracking automated from the click into Salesforce, after a free year still wasn't selling. Their homepage, as of 2026, came out of our walkthrough.

Challenge

SurePayroll, a payroll service owned by Paychex, sells to small businesses. It was offering six months and then a full year free, and new customers were still hard to win and hard to keep. Cancellations were high.

The planned answers were on the media side, including a large programmatic buy and a sports sponsorship. Before committing that money, the team asked us to fix something smaller, a tool for building campaign tracking links so it could see how email affected acquisition.

Solution

What the audit found

The tracking problem ran deeper than the links. The site moved buyers across several domains with no tracking between them, so many sign-ups showed up as referral traffic from SurePayroll's own pages. The link builder was a spreadsheet that people downloaded and edited on their own computers, and it kept breaking reporting in Salesforce.

Once sales and marketing data sat in one place, three problems showed. Television brought in the most leads, at a high cost per lead. Audio and programmatic buys were bidding against each other for the same radio inventory. Vendor results arrived as separate PDFs and spreadsheets.

The bigger finding was in the market. Competitors sold managed payroll and freedom from payroll mistakes, while SurePayroll's own reviews praised running payroll from anywhere, which still meant doing it yourself. The product trailed competitors on managed payroll. The free year attracted businesses buying payroll for the first time, which left once they could afford something better. And the push to switch at year end landed when small businesses were busiest with holiday sales and year-end taxes.

What the fix had to do

The fix had to start upstream of the media. More reach would have sent more buyers into an offer and a product that were losing them. The tracking had to stop depending on a spreadsheet anyone could change, so reporting in Salesforce matched what happened. And the recommendations had to follow how small businesses decide to buy payroll, from the trigger to the sales conversation.

What we did after the audit

We mapped the customer journey from the first click through the website to what buyers wanted to hear from a salesperson. The triggers were clear: paying someone for the first time, whether a first employee or a contractor, or leaving a provider after a problem. Each one needed its own message and its own path, where the site sent everyone to one sign-up form.

We presented the findings in a 90-minute walkthrough of the market, the competitors, the ads and what the product needed to become. We recommended starting with the product and the offer before any new media commitment, and cutting the advertising sources that looked productive but were not adding customers.

We replaced the tracking spreadsheet with an automated builder, so campaign links stayed consistent from the click into Salesforce.

What we delivered

The homepage SurePayroll runs today (2026) came out of that walkthrough. The team kept an automated tracking link builder that held Salesforce reporting together, and a journey map built on the reasons small businesses buy payroll. Its revenue operations team went on to run the work in-house.

What it made possible

SurePayroll could see what each channel and offer did to cost per lead, using its own sales data instead of vendor reports. Its homepage now follows how small businesses decide, and campaign reporting in Salesforce stopped breaking.

Key takeaway

When a free offer still does not sell, the problem sits upstream of the price. Fix the product and the offer before you buy more reach.

Industries: SaaS and technology, B2B

Know what to fix first and what to leave alone.

Find problem areas today with the Market Health Analysis. It's $350, credited toward your Diagnostic.

Get your Market Health Analysis

Book a demo

See the dashboards, and how they would read your own numbers. We’ll email you to set up a time.

We use these details only to reply to you. See our privacy policy.